These are the lecture notes from professor andrew stromingers physics 211r. Stephen hawking just published a new solution to the black. Calculations suggest that physical information could permanently disappear in a black hole, allowing many physical states to devolve into the same state. A concise survey of the black hole information paradox and its current status is given. It is the rst half of a survey of black holes focusing on the deep puzzles they present concerning the relations between general relativity, quantum mechanics and thermodynamics. The black hole information paradox, stephen hawkings. The black hole information paradox and the collapse of the. The consensus about the solution of the information paradox is not yet reached, and it is not yet clear what can we learn about quantum gravity from these and the related research. Hawkings claim that a black hole consumes information has drawn attention to a potentially serious con. As such, theyre bound to evaporate over time until theres nothing left. Starting from the schwarzschild metric, finding kruskal coordinates to cover the spacetime, and making a penrose diagram to describe the causal structure created by a collapsing shell.
Black holes quantum theory hawkings work on black holes showed that general relativity and quantum mechanics contradict each other this puzzle is known as the black hole information paradox einstein heisenberg hawking. When something falls into a black hole, one cannot expect it. New physics to the rescue we dont have a resolution to the black hole information paradox, but that hasnt stopped starryeyed theorists from dreaming up a host of potential solutions over the. Black holes redshifted redshifted into oblivion from inside this region no information can escape. Searching for that answer, physicists are groping toward a quantum theory of gravity. In this analogy, you can only separate the dbranes when they. Revisiting the black hole entropy and the information paradox arxiv.
Alessandro sfondrini and it was funded by snsf under. The main difficulties stem from confusions about black holes, thermodynamics, quantum unitarity, encoding of information in correlations, the role of adscft etc. Some consider this to be the real black hole information paradox 72. However, one could, in principle, put it back together. As the black hole evaporates, there is not a trace of this initial information in the observable universe. Imagine a black hole formed by concentrating a sufficient amount of matter.
On behalf of the organizers and the faculty participating in the programme, welcome to the gian course on the black hole information paradox. We conclude with recent results on the quantum physics of black holes which show. Hologram within a hologram hints at fate of black holes. The information paradox arose from hawkings theoretical argument back in the 1970s that black holes have a temperature. He has suggested that theres a way that new hawking radiation. Black holes and the information paradox in string theory. Wait long enough, and the 18 scientific american updated from the april 1997 issue black holes information paradox and the black holes surfacelooks to windbag in the spaceship like a spherical membrane, called the horizon. Abstractions black hole information paradox black holes gravity physics quantum gravity quantum physics theoretical physics the renowned british physicist stephen hawking, who died today at 76, was something of a betting man, regularly entering into friendly wagers with his colleagues over key questions in theoretical physics.
This is the essence of the black hole information paradox bhip. In this case, the information paradox would be solved. I will argue in these notes that each phrase in the above conversation is either incorrect or is irrelevant to the information problem. The case of black holes is similar to this latter situation, where one has to keep track of variables that involve pairs of dbranes, rather than single dbranes.
The black hole information paradox, however, is that all the information that was imprinted on the event horizon of the black hole, once it evaporates, has left no trace in our observable universe. One of the important aspects of the thermodynamics of black holes relates to the black hole information paradox. It is often believed that hawkings argument is not precisely formulated, and a more careful accounting of naturally occurring quantum corrections will allow the radiation process to become unitary. The black hole information paradox arises from an apparent conflict between the hawk ing black hole radiation and the fact that time evolution in quantum. Pdf black hole information paradox resolution george.
From timetraveling billiard balls to informationdestroying black holes, the worlds got plenty of puzzles that are hard to wrap your head around. Namely, the radiation coming out of black holes would be completely thermal and devoid of the information of what fell into black holes. When something falls into a black hole, one cannot expect it ever. Hawkings work on black holes showed that general relativity and quantum mechanics contradict each other. Black holes redshifted redshifted into oblivion from inside this. This is expected to be an intensive 2week course, with lectures, tutorials and discussions. His argument was based on the fact that particle emission from a. The black hole information paradox college of arts and sciences. That would require, at a minimum, a detailed understanding of the information flow out of black holes as well as a derivation of the hawkingbekenstein areaentropy law 2,3,42. Oct 29, 2015 and maybe, physicists will never figure it out. The black hole information paradox lecture 1 samir d. These can be argued to lead to an unacceptable infinite production rate of such black holes in. His argument was based on the fact that particle emission from a black hole, so called the hawking radiation, cannot convey any information from its interior region. Perhaps there is no solution to this paradox yet and it presents a serious problem for physics.
Moreover, a problem seems to occur long before the complete evaporation, since the black hole entropy seems to increase during evaporation, until the page time is reached 77. The black hole information paradox arises from an apparent con. The black hole information paradox the paradox arose after hawking showed, in 19741975, that black holes surrounded by quantum fields actually will radiate particles hawking radiation and shrink in size figure 4, eventually evaporating completely. Wind bag sees goulash, who is falling into the black hole, as being slowed down and flattened at the horizon. A summary is also given of recent arguments against remnants. Gian lectures on the black hole information paradox. This in turn, will determine varying delays in the emission of wave packets. Engines of destruction, swallowers of light and an infinite source of wonder and mystery for astronomers. Why the black hole information paradox is such a problem. Hawking s claim that a black hole consumes infor mation has drawn attention to a potentially serious con. Black holes, hawking radiation, and the information paradoxy g. Nov 19, 2019 abstractions black hole information paradox black holes physics theoretical physics like cosmic hard drives, black holes pack troves of data into compact spaces.
Black holes, hawking radiation, universiteit utrecht. We know there will always be small corrections from quantum gravity. It seems that the apparently irreducible paradoxes force us to give up on at least one wellestablished principle. In electromagnetism, like charges repel, opposite charges attract. In 1991, hawking and kip thorne bet preskill that information that falls into a black hole gets destroyed and can never be retrieved. The most famous of these conundrums is the information paradox, which is based on the following thought experiment. Mar 29, 2018 the black hole information paradox, however, is that all the information that was imprinted on the event horizon of the black hole, once it evaporates, has left no trace in our observable universe. Pdf the black hole information paradox semantic scholar. We argue that the following three statements cannot all be true. But ever since stephen hawking calculated in 1974 that these dense spheres of extreme gravity give off heat and fade away, the fate of their stored information has haunted physicists. The black hole information paradox college of arts and. The problem with black holes is with the information that goes into them. The result of absolute gravitational collapse of a massive body. Because of the radiation process of the black hole, the previously pure state of the matter inside.
Light emitted close to the critical surface is severely redshifted the frequency is lower and at the critical surface, the redshift is infinite. The black hole information paradox is a puzzle resulting from the combination of quantum mechanics and general relativity. If black holes withheld information forever in their singularities, there would be a fundamental flaw with quantum mechanics. But they also might reveal the true nature of the universe to us. Firstly we take a brief look into the history of black holes, some of the most useful mathematical. If we make the coupling large, we expected a black hole but in all the cases that have been worked out, we always get a fuzzball 2 charge extremal solved completely, 3 charge extremal, near extremal. The black hole information paradox umd department of computer. Oct, 2018 the information paradox arose from hawkings theoretical argument back in the 1970s that black holes have a temperature. By applying general relativity and quantum field theory on curved spacetime, hawking arrives at the conclusion that the information is lost in the. Black hole s surface looks to windbag in the spaceship like a spheri cal membrane, called the horizon. The black hole information paradox and the black hole entropy are currently extensively researched. This puzzle is known as the black hole information.
The significance of the information paradox came to a head in 1997 when hawking, together with kip thorne of the california institute of technology caltech in the us, placed a bet with john preskill, also of caltech. The information paradox arises because of the creation of hawking radiation. For low mass black holes, no credible formation process is known, and indeed no indications have been found that black holes much lighter than this \chandrasekhar limit exist. If that could remove the entanglement, why would we be worrying about the information. If n is a thousand, you need a megabit of information. The trouble is that while the former suggests that information of a system falling into a black hole disappears, the latter implies that information must be conserved.
Hawking suggested that black holes imply that this basic principle of quantum mechanics would not hold in the presence of gravity. That black holes are the ultimate vaults, entities that suck in information and then evaporate without leaving behind any clues as to what they once contained. A remarkable feature of the gravitational force is that like masses attract. Hawking recently proposed a new idea to resolve the black hole information paradox. Revisiting the black hole entropy and the information paradox. Due to these confusions we fail to appreciate the enormous power of hawkings paradox, and thus fail to realize that we will have to make a basic change in our understanding of how.
Called the black hole information paradox, this prospect follows from hawkings landmark 1974 discovery about black holes regions of inescapable gravity, where spacetime curves steeply toward a central point known as the singularity. Next, theoretical physicists try to penetrate more deeply into the black hole mystery by using tools such as general relativity, quantum mechanics and higher mathematics. Abstractions black hole information paradox black holes physics theoretical physics like cosmic hard drives, black holes pack troves of data into compact spaces. Windbag sees goulash, who is falling into the black hole, being slowed down and. The black hole information paradox and the collapse of the wave. Hawking, information loss in black holes, hepth0507171 norihiro tanahashi department of physics, kyoto university december 26, 2005 abstract the information paradox of black holes was raised in 1975 by s. In the universe as we understand it, there are certain. Black holes from a to z course given in spring 2015, at harvard university. String theory and the black hole information paradox dummies. Black holes are regions of space so incredibly dense that nothing, not even light, can escape from them. By that i mean black holes would compress matter and energy into an infinitely dense singularity, and didnt create a seemingly insurmountable information paradox. This radiation arises because the black hole has a horizon, inside which the time coordinate t actually becomes spacelike. Nevertheless, the information paradox of black holes is a real problem.
The assumptions underlying remnants, namely unitarity and causality, would imply that reissner nordstrom black holes have infinite internal states. The information paradox has arisen when hawking wrote down his theory for radiating black holes. Box 80 006 3508 ta utrecht, the netherlands abstract the physical degrees of freedom and the dynamics of their evolution at the planck length are investigated by performing thought experiments with black holes. So the information paradox is a combination of two observations. Jun 20, 2018 weve established by now that black holes are weird. Jan 11, 2016 first, the black hole information paradox. For all practical purposes, however, the information is lost. In this letter we take some steps in that direction. The information paradox, first found by hawking in 1975, is perhaps the most important issue in fu.
The black hole information paradox arises from an apparent conflict between the hawking black hole radiation and the fact that time evolution in quantum mechanics is unitary. This paradox may well have a solution in string theory, either in the string theory analyses described in the previous section or in the holographic principle. The black hole information paradox is a very poorly understood problem. The problem with black holes is that according to einsteins general theory of relativity, because of what we know about how gravity interacts with the universe and everything in it, all information that crosses the boundary of a black hole called the event horizon is lost forever.
Nevertheless, there are two options for its possible solution. Thus we begin by working out the spacetime geometry of the black hole. What is the information paradox of black holes vop today. Stephen hawkings last paper on black holes is now online. A black hole is a region in space where the force of gravity is so strong, not. According to einstein, at the age of 15 he formulated the following paradox. Pdf the black hole information paradox researchgate. The information about the ingoing particles is returned, but in a highly scrambled, chaotic and useless form. Black hole entropy gas with entropy s suppose we throw a box of gas into a black hole. The information paradox of black holes was raised in 1975 by s. Astronomers found that black holes can only form from normal stellar objects if these represent a minimal amount of mass, being several times the mass of the sun. We expect that the resolution to this paradox, or its con rmation, lies in a full quantum theory of gravity. Weve established by now that black holes are weird.
1288 728 470 774 820 827 1154 643 68 1173 109 877 978 892 47 136 771 212 641 257 328 1463 1484 1348 615 16 950 700 982 355 322 1286 1363 1451 468 467 1085 35 660 1479 502 1310 596 852 1466 617 1105 21